The Ryder Cup Reckoning: What Went Wrong for the U.S. at Bethpage and What’s Next

The echoes of cheers and groans from Bethpage Black have faded, but the sting of defeat lingers. The 45th Ryder Cup concluded, once again, with the European squad lifting the coveted trophy, marking their 11th victory in the last 15 contests against the United States. Despite a valiant Sunday singles rally, the 15-13 scoreline for Europe only thinly veiled the systemic issues plaguing American team golf. It`s a familiar narrative, and as the U.S. team prepares for an uphill battle on foreign soil in 2027, a thorough introspection is not merely advisable, but imperative.

The European Enigma: A Masterclass in Unity

Europe’s consistent dominance isn’t an accident. It’s a meticulously crafted machine, refined over decades, that seems to operate with a near-telepathic understanding. Captain Luke Donald, now a back-to-back victor, has cemented his legacy as arguably the greatest European Ryder Cup captain. His leadership, buttressed by a robust support system — including tactical guru Edoardo Molinari and experienced former captains like Thomas Bjørn and Paul McGinley — paints a stark contrast to the American approach.

As U.S. Captain Keegan Bradley candidly admitted, Donald’s Europeans were an “unstoppable force,” particularly in the critical opening days. The continuity within the European camp, where players like Rory McIlroy, Tommy Fleetwood, and Jon Rahm are expected to return, fosters a deep sense of camaraderie and shared purpose. They don`t just play for themselves; they play for the crest, the legacy, and each other. It’s a blueprint that, while seemingly simple, has proven frustratingly inimitable for their American counterparts.

America`s Ailing Arsenal: Diagnosis and Prescription

The U.S. team, despite boasting an embarrassment of individual talent, continues to struggle when the formats shift from stroke play to match play. The loss at Bethpage Black highlighted several cracks in the American foundation.

The Captaincy Conundrum

Keegan Bradley, a rookie Ryder Cup captain, acknowledged mistakes, particularly concerning the course setup at Bethpage Black. This isn`t just about one captain; it’s about a broader organizational strategy. The revelation that Bradley wasn`t even considered until 2023 captain Zach Johnson`s eleventh-hour call, after months of waiting for Tiger Woods to decline, speaks volumes about a reactive, rather than proactive, approach.

Looking ahead to Adare Manor in 2027, the 100th anniversary of the Ryder Cup, Tiger Woods remains the favorite for captaincy. His stature is undeniable, but the PGA of America cannot afford another prolonged waiting game. A two-year commitment is crucial. If Woods opts out, names like Brandt Snedeker, Webb Simpson, Justin Leonard, or even the ever-popular Fred Couples — a five-time Ryder Cupper who commands respect from the current generation — are on the table. The continuity argument, a European strength, also weighs on the minds of some who believe Bradley deserves another shot, given the respect he clearly earned from his players.

Beyond the Putts: The Search for Team Spirit

When asked if Donald “out-captained” him, Justin Thomas`s sarcastic interjection — “We needed to make more putts. That`s what Keegan needed!” — while defensive, pointed to a fundamental truth. But the problem runs deeper than simply sinking putts. Europe`s “sense of purpose, camaraderie, and unity” transcends individual performance. They draw inspiration from their history and channel a collective desire to win for each other. The Americans, for all their individual brilliance, have yet to consistently forge that same intangible bond.

Even Scottie Scheffler, the world`s best individual golfer, found himself bewildered by his Ryder Cup performance. Going 0-4 in team matches, including 0-4-0 in foursomes across three Ryder Cups, highlights a critical difference between dominating individual tournaments and excelling in team formats. As Scheffler himself described it, this week was one of the “lowest moments” of his career. He cares deeply, but team play demands a different “muscle” – one the U.S. desperately needs to develop.

Perhaps it`s time to mimic Europe`s successful pairing strategy: putting their strongest players together, like McIlroy with Fleetwood or Rahm with Hatton, to guarantee points in critical sessions.

The Road Ahead: Irish Horizons and Home Comforts

The next two Ryder Cup venues present distinct challenges and opportunities for the U.S.

Adare Manor, Ireland (2027)

Adare Manor, while a parkland-style resort course atypical of traditional Irish links, will still represent foreign soil. The Europeans will, without doubt, maximize their home advantage in course setup. Given the U.S.`s seven consecutive away losses since 1993, it`s difficult to envision them being favored. The centennial Ryder Cup could be another stern test of character.

Hazeltine National Golf Club, Minnesota (2029)

A glimmer of hope appears on the horizon with Hazeltine National. This was the site where the U.S. ended a three-match losing streak with a dominant 17-11 victory in 2016. A return to familiar ground, where a past success story was written, could provide the mental lift needed.

Rebuilding the Foundation: A Call for a New Task Force

The U.S. team`s recurring struggles are not new. The 2016 Hazeltine triumph followed the formation of a Ryder Cup Task Force, an initiative aimed at examining the systemic issues after a period of European dominance. With Europe now “crushing them 365 days a year,” it seems another such task force is not just warranted, but essential. It`s time for a long, hard look at what has gone wrong for the better part of three decades and to implement lasting structural changes, not just temporary fixes.

The Gentleman`s Game and the Raucous Crowd

Beyond the strategic and personnel changes, there`s another crucial aspect: the fan experience. The behavior at Bethpage Black, described as a “drunken fraternity party,” was an embarrassment to the game. While a home-course advantage is part of the Ryder Cup`s allure, it doesn`t grant license for obscenities and disrespect. Augusta National manages to control its patrons with surgical precision every year; there`s no excuse for the PGA of America not to do the same. Golf, at its heart, remains a gentleman`s game, and that respect should extend to the spectators.

Shaping Tomorrow`s Roster: Veterans and Virtuosos

Panic and wholesale roster changes are likely unnecessary, but a clear vision for the future is vital. The core of the team—Scottie Scheffler, Xander Schauffele, Justin Thomas, Bryson DeChambeau, and arguably Cameron Young (who was the U.S. team MVP at Bethpage with a 3-1-0 record)—seems secure, provided health and form hold.

Beyond this core, competition for the remaining spots will be fierce. Players like Collin Morikawa and Patrick Cantlay, with their Ryder Cup experience, will be strong contenders if they maintain form. The younger generation offers exciting prospects. Keep an eye on the world`s top amateur, Jackson Koivun, who already has a PGA Tour card locked up and multiple top-10 finishes as an amateur. Luke Clanton, another promising young talent, is also showing flashes of brilliance. Their success, much like Cameron Young`s at Bethpage, reminds us that raw talent and current form can often outweigh mere experience.

The next two years will be a crucial audition, with major wins and strong performances in signature events serving as undeniable statements for those aspiring to don the American colors in Ireland.

---

The road to redemption for the U.S. Ryder Cup team is long and winding, fraught with challenges both tactical and psychological. But with a renewed commitment to continuity, a willingness to learn from their European rivals` successes, and a focus on fostering genuine team unity, perhaps the script of perennial defeat can finally be rewritten. The next chapter begins now.